Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer | Which Is Better?

You are planning to build your dream home theater or man cave. While you’ve figured out the rest of the components (amplifiers, main speakers, etc.), you feel stuck when choosing the right subwoofer or the type of subwoofer enclosure to be specific. Don’t worry. You are not alone as this is one of the popular questions among beginners and newbie audio enthusiasts; ported vs. sealed subwoofer, which type of subwoofer enclosure is better?

Any high-end audio setup is incomplete without a proper subwoofer, the special speaker that produces the low-frequency bass. If you look at the subwoofer market, things can get a bit confusing when we have two main enclosure options: Sealed and Ported. In this guide, we will try to break things down and look at the basics of both Ported and Sealed subwoofers. In the process, we will look at the quirks and pros & cons of each subwoofer type so that it can help you make the right choice.

What Is The Purpose Of A Subwoofer?

There has been a lot of improvement in the “electronics” of high-end audio systems over the years. But the speakers or the actual sound-making part of them remain more or less the same. Yes, the sound quality is much better than what it used to be, thanks to the improvement in the quality of components and material. However, the basic design of the speaker hasn’t changed.

Speaking of design, a typical speaker consists of a tweeter, woofer, crossover, and the speaker enclosure. Tweeter and woofer are the names of the individual speakers (commonly known as drivers) in a speaker system. The reason behind this is simple. No one speaker can reproduce the entire audible frequency range. What the “audio folk” has done is they designed different speakers that can handle a particular portion of the audio frequency range.

Tweeter, which is usually smaller in design, can handle the upper range of the audio spectrum (usually between 2,000Hz to 20,000Hz) for reproducing instruments and vocals. A woofer on the other hand can move large volumes of air that is necessary to reproduce the lower end of the audio spectrum. The rumbles and the booms we hear in movies is the specialty of woofers.

Then what about subwoofers? Subwoofers are a special type of woofer that reproduces low-frequency sounds or bass in audio systems, lower than a regular woofer can go. Subwoofers are specifically designed to handle and enhance the deep tones that regular speakers or woofers might struggle to reproduce adequately.

These low-frequency sounds not only add richness and depth to music but also contribute to the immersive experience in home theaters and audio setups. Subwoofers allow listeners to feel the impact of explosions in movies, the thump of a kick drum in music, or the rumble of a car engine in video games.

Importance Of Subwoofer Design

The speaker drivers (sometimes even crossovers) are encased in an enclosure (or a box). Its design plays an important role in the final audio reproduction of the speaker i.e., how they sound. Speakers are highly directional but every speaker produces sound in front as well as behind the driver. The front sound wave is the one pointed at the listener while the back sound goes in the exact opposite direction.

If these two sounds somehow combine, they would cancel each other out (especially if they are out of phase). As a result, the speaker will not produce any sound or greatly diminish the low-frequency sound. Hence, the design of a speaker enclosure, especially a subwoofer, has a huge impact on how it handles the backward sound wave.

The two design approaches for subwoofer enclosure design are: Acoustic Suspension and Bass Reflex or you will better know them as Sealed Box and Ported-cabinet respectively.

What Are Sealed Subwoofers?

Sealed-box or Closed-box Subwoofers are also known as Acoustic Suspension Subwoofers. It is a simple design that puts the subwoofer driver and the crossover in a tightly sealed enclosure. As far as the output is concerned, sealed subwoofers are famous for their accurate, clean, and natural sound production with strong and tight bass.

The design of the sealed subwoofer helps in isolating the front of the driver with the back. As the entire rear section of the driver sits in a sealed chamber with sound absorption material, the back sound waves are trapped inside the box with nowhere to go. This means the rear sound won’t radiate forward and importantly doesn’t interfere or disrupt the main sound of the speaker.

Due to the design aspects, the size of the sealed subwoofer is usually small and compact. But the overall construction is very rigid (using 3/4” or 1” thick MDF or plywood) to prevent unwanted box vibrations or resonance. Some models might even include internal bracings to provide extra stiffness.

As the sealed box subwoofer is losing a significant portion of sound energy in the form of trapped/unused back sound waves, the overall efficiency is very low. For the same sound output, it needs a slightly larger and powerful amplifier.

What Are Ported Subwoofers?

Bass Reflex Subwoofers, also known as Ported or Vented Subwoofers,  is another style of speaker design that has been popular since the early 1930s. As the name suggests, the enclosure of a Vented-box Subwoofer has an opening in the form of a vent, port, or duct from inside of the cabinet to the ambient environment.

The shape of the port is typically cylindrical with the end pointing outside being flanged. There will be no (or very minimal) use of acoustic material inside the enclosure. As a result, the air inside the cabinet can move freely through the port.

Such an opening will carry some of the back sound waves to the front and combine with the main sound. With proper tuning of the design, the back sound wave will be in phase with the main sound and acts as a reinforcement. The result is a strong, loud, and wide-ranging bass sound that can be boomy but slightly less accurate.

As a Ported Subwoofer uses some portion of the back sound wave, its efficiency is much higher than a Sealed Subwoofer. You can get away with a smaller amplifier for the same sound output. An important caveat of the design of ported subwoofers is their large size since the enclosure needs to accommodate a vent inside.

Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer: Timing

When we say “timing” in subwoofers, we are talking about how the low-frequency audio from a subwoofer is in sync (or not in sync) with the rest of the audio setup (usually the main speakers that reproduce vocals and instruments).

The design of a sealed subwoofer is very close to that of most of the other speakers in a typical audio system. From a design perspective, sealed subwoofers do not typically have a problem syncing the sound output of the subwoofer from the rest of the audio. All we need is a system with light tuning. However, amplifiers in most high-end sealed subwoofers have some sort of mechanism (usually a time delay adjustment) to sync the audio manually.

Things are slightly complicated in this aspect for the ported subwoofers. While the sound from the main subwoofer speaker can be pretty in sync with the rest of the audio, the sound/air from the port might not be. Hence, the design of the cabinet and the port plays an important role in the tuning of the overall sound output.

In a properly tuned ported subwoofer, the design of the vent adds a phase shift to the back sound wave. The delay due to this will help in syncing sound from the port with the main subwoofer speaker. Cheap quality ported subwoofers might not have a perfectly tuned design.

Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer: Bass/Sound Quality

Due to the design of sealed subwoofers, the back sound wave or air inside the cabinet acts as a spring or suspension that helps in the accurate movement of the speaker cone. It also helps in the quick movement of the cone from equilibrium or resting position to the high excursion (maximum linear point of travel).

As a result, the subwoofers might not rattle the windows in your house or in your car but produce very accurate and “tight or quick” bass. You can still feel the thump but the bass is more natural. Such subwoofers are more suitable for listening to music content where the bass needs to be tighter rather than louder. While this is true for soft and classical music, you need some extra oomph if you listen to rock, pop, or EDM, which a ported subwoofer can provide.

Speaking of which, a ported subwoofer can move a lot of air, thanks to the inclusion of a vent or port in its enclosure. As a result, the bass will be much louder and boomy that it sounds like thunder or roar. You can not only hear the bass but feel it too. The bass from a ported subwoofer will be slightly less accurate and lacks the “tightness” that you get from a sealed subwoofer. If you are a movie buff, you need a “cinematic” experience from the audio system. The seats must vibrate, and you should feel the explosion thump in your chest; basically, you must be right in the middle of the action. This is where a decent ported subwoofer excels, thanks to its louder and more resonant bass.

Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer: Bass Roll-off

The low-frequency roll-off or bass roll-off is an important factor to consider when purchasing a subwoofer. The quality of the bass produced by the subwoofer is dependent not only on the lowest frequency that it can reproduce but also on the steepness of the roll-off below this frequency.

Bass Roll-off is a measure of how much bass a subwoofer can produce below its cutoff frequency (low-frequency response). For example, if the cutoff frequency of a subwoofer is 45Hz, you will still hear some base even at 30Hz, but it may not be that loud or punchy.

A subwoofer with a slightly higher low-frequency response (say 60Hz for example) with a slow roll-off is better than a subwoofer with a lower low-frequency response (say 45Hz) but with a quick roll-off.

The design of the subwoofer plays a crucial role in the steepness of the low-frequency roll-off. Generally, a high-end sealed subwoofer rolls off at 12dB per octave compared to 24dB per octave for a high-end ported subwoofer. What this means is that a ported subwoofer generally rolls off twice as fast as sealed subwoofers, which is not a desirable feature.

Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer: Transient Response

Another thing you need to consider is the transient response or how quickly and effectively can a subwoofer adjust to the dynamics of the audio without any distortion and overhanging.

In simple words, when to start playing bass and when to stop it in correspondence to the audio. Subwoofers, like any loudspeaker, resonate the cone in response to the electrical signals. If there is a sudden transient, then the vibrations must stop as soon as possible. It may not be instant but they must decay faster.

Sealed subwoofers have better transient response than their ported counterparts thanks to the “acoustic suspension” aspect of the enclosure design. This is very important while you play music but might not be critical (or that important) for bombastic action movies.

Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer: SPL And Excursion

Excursion in a subwoofer is an indication of the lateral movement of the cone of the subwoofer. A subwoofer with higher excursion can produce very accurate bass.

Another important specification of a subwoofer is the Sound Pressure Level or SPL. It is a measure of how loud the subwoofer (or any speaker for that matter) can get and is usually measured in decibels (dB). A subwoofer with higher SPL values can produce louder and more impactful bass.

Generally, ported subwoofers tend to have significantly higher SPL values than a similarly sized sealed subwoofer, thanks to its ported-box design. To get the same frequency response and SPL levels of a ported subwoofer, the size of the sealed subwoofer must be very large.

Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer: Room Size And Aesthetics

If you are worried about a subwoofer occupying too much space in your home theater, living room, or den, then the size of the subwoofer plays an important role in the aesthetics of the room. Generally, sealed subwoofers can be significantly smaller than ported subwoofers.

Ported subwoofers can easily “fill up” a large room compared to a sealed subwoofer. So, if you want to place a subwoofer in your home theater, where you will be playing a lot of action movies with a lot of booms, explosions, and crashes that you want to listen to as well as feel, then a large ported subwoofer is a better choice. If you wish to go with a sealed subwoofer however, you might need not one but two subwoofers to fulfill the “bass” demands of a large room. As a general rule of thumb, any room that is larger than 75m3 will need a large ported subwoofer or two sealed subwoofers.

If you place the subwoofer in an open spot that is clearly visible with the rest of the things in a room, then the aesthetic or design elements of the subwoofer can be critical. Most sealed-box subwoofers have a simple cubic design that can easily blend in with most rooms without causing a distraction.

Ported subwoofers, due to their extra cabinet space requirements (to accommodate the vent/port), can have a slightly larger footprint.

Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer: Power Requirements And Efficiency

The design aspects of both ported and sealed subwoofers tend to influence the overall power of the amplifier driving the subwoofer speaker. As a sealed subwoofer blocks or seals the back sound wave from the subwoofer driver, we are essentially wasting so much sound energy just to get accurate or tighter reproduction of bass.

Ported subwoofers are much better in this regard as they make use of the back sound wave with a simple yet clever design of the cabinet and reinforce the main sound.

As a result, when using a similar powered amplifier, you are likely to get more sound output from a ported subwoofer than a sealed subwoofer.

Ported vs. Sealed Subwoofer: Pros And Cons

Ported Subwoofers

Pros Cons
Loud and punchy bass that can rattle windows Can be large and bulky
Good power efficiency Expensive
Suitable for most applications (music as well as movies)
Better SPL (at a cost of accuracy)

Sealed Subwoofers

Pros Cons
Smaller in size and compact in design Bass lacks thunderous punch or reverberance
Tight and accurate bass Less efficient
Cheaper
Better transient response and slower bass roll-off

Which One To Get, Sealed Or Ported Subwoofer?

The answer isn’t as simple as “get a sealed subwoofer if you listen to music and a ported one if you are a movie buff.” But this is generally true for most users. Sealed subwoofers, with their tight and accurate bass and better transient response, are more suitable for listening to natural-sounding music. They are small and can be perfect for small media rooms.

Does this mean they aren’t suitable for watching movies or home theater setups? You can absolutely use a sealed subwoofer for watching movies. However, you might not feel the punchy and boomy effects in the room/seat that you expect from a typical action movie due to the lack of the higher SPL. When you crank things up, sealed subwoofers tend to experience distortion.

Ported subwoofers on the other hand have excellent SPL values. When you combine this with their typically louder and boomy bass, it makes more sense to use them in your home theaters and large media rooms. As the size of the ported subwoofers is generally large, slightly powerful ones can easily fill-up a large room. What about music? You can definitely use ported subwoofers to listen to music.

If you need a subwoofer for dual purpose i.e., to listen to music as well as watch action music, then a ported subwoofer makes a lot of sense. However, they can be more expensive than sealed counterparts.

As a final word, the right subwoofer between ported and sealed will entirely depend on your room size, audio preference (music/movie), bass quality, and importantly budget. If you are on a tight budget (say $500), then you are better off with a sealed subwoofer as cheap and low-cost ported subwoofers sound terrible. However, for budgets up to $2,000, a good-quality ported subwoofer is a perfect choice.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *