Pool maintenance isn’t an easy task, you need to do a lot for its proper maintenance, which can be challenging. But it’s not with a saltwater pool system.
Saltwater pool systems (AKA Chlorinators or Chlorine Generators) are becoming popular these days due to their ease of maintenance, affordability, and other benefits compared to traditional chlorine-based systems. This system runs electrolysis to convert salt into chlorine and thereby uses less chemicals to keep the water clean. Thus, it prevents algae issues, contaminant build-up, and chloramines. They provide automated maintenance for your oasis with higher salt concentration, offering a comfortable swimming experience without any irritation.
To simplify your selection process easy, here are the 3 common yet key factors to be considered:
- Pool Size And Shape – The pool size will determine the required salt quantity and different filtration equipment. A larger pool needs more salt than a smaller pool size. Coming to a pool shape, a round or square-shaped pool is easier to clean than curvy-shaped pools. So, choose wisely as required.
- Salt Cell Capacity – The output capacity of the salt cell determines how much chlorine the system produces. Based on the pool capacity, you need to choose the generator with the required salt cell capacity (either low, moderate, high, or very high).
- Water Flow Rate – The filtration system (its type and condition) affects the water flow rate that the salt cell produces chlorine and removes contaminants. A larger pump will offer a higher water flow rate than a small pump size.
For a more comprehensive understanding of saltwater pool systems, we have listed the Top Saltwater Pool Systems with detailed explanations along with a “Buying Guide” to make a proper buying decision that suits your pool maintenance requirements.
7 Best Salt Water Pool Systems Table
| Salt Water Pool System | Speed Capability | Salt Cell Life | Buy Now |
|---|---|---|---|
| Intex Salt Water Water Pool System | up to 15,000 Gallons | Moderate | Check On Amazon |
| Hayward W3AQ-TROL-RJ Salt Water Pool System | up to 18,000 Gallons | High | Check On Amazon |
| ControlOMatic Salt Water Pool System | up to 17,000 Gallons | Moderate | Check On Amazon |
| Saltron Mini Salt Water Pool System | up to 2000 Gallons | Moderate | Check On Amazon |
| CircuPool CORE55 Salt Water Pool System | up to 55,000 Gallons | Very High | Check On Amazon |
| Bestway Salt Water Pool System | 7,000 gallons | Low | Check On Amazon |
| ChlorWorks Salt Water Pool System | 25,000 Gallons | High | Check On Amazon |
7 Best Salt Water Pool Systems Reviews
Whether you want to install a new pool system or looking to convert your present chlorine pool into a saltwater pool, you will definitely think of “Which saltwater system is perfect for your pool?” Don’t worry, here’s a detailed description of saltwater pool systems that we have carefully researched and reviewed.
Take a look into these saltwater pool systems….
1. Intex Salt Water Water Pool System
Intex’s saltwater pool system transforms traditional pool care by automating chlorine production. Designed for above-ground pools, this system works with your existing filter pump and uses salt to create chlorine, providing hands-off sanitization. Based on my personal testing, its ease of use and efficiency in keeping the pool water clear make it an excellent choice for hassle-free maintenance.
Harnessing advanced filtration technology, the system ensures consistently clean and refreshing water. The control panel is a standout, offering intuitive access to a range of settings like cycle durations and chlorine levels. Users particularly value the HydroAeration Technology, which not only improves water circulation but also enhances the overall quality of the pool environment.
Operational ease is a strong point of the system; however, durability and customer support issues present ongoing challenges for users. When evaluating this system, potential buyers must consider these factors, as they play crucial roles in user satisfaction and the overall quality of the experience. Balancing these considerations is key to making an informed decision.
Specifications:
- Brand: Intex
- Weight: 17.1 pounds
- Form: Granular salt
- Maximum Pool Volume: 15,000 gallons
- Required Flow Rate: 700-3,000 GPH
- Includes HydroAeration Technology
- Automatic chlorine generation
- User-friendly control panel
- Self-cleaning function
- Salt needed for operation
Pros:
- Simplifies chemical management
- Cost-effective maintenance
- Quick and easy installation
- Improves water clarity
- Energy-efficient operation
Cons:
- Possible component failures
- Initial frequent backwashing
- Regular salt level monitoring is needed
2. Hayward W3AQ-TROL-RJ Salt Water Pool System
Hayward’s W3AQ-TROL-RJ transforms pool care with its advanced saltwater system designed for above-ground pools. This system is incredibly easy to install, often completed in less than 30 minutes, making setup a breeze. Once running, it efficiently manages essential maintenance tasks, keeping chlorine levels balanced and water consistently clear, all with minimal effort.
Simplify your pool maintenance with the innovative 24-hour timer integrated into this system, allowing for multiple pump periods each day keeping your pool swim-ready effortlessly. This feature not only automates the daily management of your pool but ensures that it remains pristine and inviting without the need for constant supervision. Furthermore, the built-in microprocessor automates various system functions and, it consistently manages the water’s chlorine levels, making manual adjustments almost obsolete.
Despite these advantages, the system’s long-term reliability can be a concern, with some users reporting issues related to the control panel and customer service experiences. These factors are crucial in considering the overall value of the investment, as ongoing support and durable construction are essential for continual satisfaction with such a system.
Specifications:
- Brand: Hayward
- Weight: 23.8 pounds
- Form: Liquid, Tablet
- Designed for pools up to 18,000 gallons
- 24-hour timer included
- Microprocessor automates functions
- Quick 30-minute installation
- Return jet fittings included
- Digital salt display
- Selectable super chlorinate function
Pros:
- Simplifies chemical handling
- Quick and easy setup
- Consistent water quality
- Low energy consumption
- Reliable chlorine generation
Cons:
- Potential control panel issues
- Requires specific installation conditions
- Limited to certain pool sizes
- Some units may need frequent recalibration
3. ControlOMatic Salt Water Pool System
ControlOMatic’s MegaChlor system simplifies pool maintenance by eliminating the complexity of plumbing installations for spa and small pool owners who seek trouble-free chlorination. Its plug-and-play capability was a key highlight in product evaluations, offering remarkable convenience. Additionally, the straightforward method of immersing the electrode in the water makes chlorination a breeze, even for those with no technical background.
With ten adjustable power levels, this system tailors chlorine production to your pool’s unique demands, ensuring perfect water balance effortlessly. The design emphasizes user-friendliness and maintenance ease, featuring a self-cleaning reverse polarity system that significantly reduces the time needed for upkeep. Precise adjustments in chlorine output ensure that water quality remains optimal with minimal effort required from the user.
The system offers a user-friendly solution for small-scale pool owners, ensuring ease of use and effective water treatment. However, its capabilities are less pronounced in larger pool settings, where performance tends to diminish. Users have also raised concerns about the durability of the electrode after extended use, and the process of securing help from customer support can be less than straightforward, potentially impacting overall satisfaction.
Specifications:
- Brand: ControlOMatic
- Weight: 27.22 grams
- Made in the USA
- Self-cleaning technology
- Ten power levels
- Plug-and-play setup
- Suitable for spas and small pools
- Includes test strips
- 12 VDC power supply
Pros:
- No plumbing required
- Easy installation and use
- Adjustable chlorine levels
- Gentle on skin and eyes
- Efficient in small volumes
Cons:
- Not for larger pools
- Electrode durability concerns
- Requires frequent salt adjustments
- May require accessory purchases
4. Saltron Mini Salt Water Pool System
The Saltron mini saltwater pool system provides an innovative and practical solution for hot tub and small pool owners looking to transition to a saltwater setup. Its compact design, along with a straightforward installation process, eliminates the need for plumbing or professional assistance, making it ideal for DIY enthusiasts. The system efficiently converts a small amount of salt into chlorine, ensuring consistently clean water while minimizing the harsh effects associated with traditional chlorine treatments.
This system is especially beneficial for those with sensitive skin, as the chlorine produced is much milder and more natural compared to standard methods. The Saltron Mini also features a built-in timer/controller with LED indicators, which simplifies the management of chlorine levels, allowing for consistent and reliable water quality.
Known for its simplicity in both installation and usage, the Saltron Mini may not meet the needs of larger pools or hot tubs, given its limited capacity. There have also been mixed reviews on the electrolytic cell’s longevity, with some users encountering frequent issues and repairs over time.
Specifications:
- Brand: Saltron Mini
- Produces chlorine from natural salt
- Suitable for up to 2000 gallons
- Built-in timer and controller
- LED indicator lights
- Ultra-low energy consumption
- Simple plug-in installation
- Titanium electrolytic cell
- Cell holder included
Pros:
- No complex installation required
- Gentle on skin and eyes
- Energy-efficient operation
- Maintains consistent chlorine levels
- Compact and easily manageable
Cons:
- Limited to small water volumes
- Potential for frequent cell replacement
- May not suit larger pools or spas
- Requires careful water balance management
5. CircuPool CORE55 Salt Water Pool System
The CircuPool CORE55 saltwater system is designed to handle pools as large as 55,000 gallons, offering a powerful solution for clean, saltwater pool maintenance. Built with a USA-made titanium cell, this system stands out for its durability and efficiency. The sleek, compact design fits effortlessly into different pool setups, ensuring that installation is a breeze. Its robust construction ensures that it will last, making it an ideal option for larger pool environments.
This system comes loaded with automated features, including a self-cleaning mechanism that drastically reduces maintenance and a digital control panel that allows for precise and easy chlorine adjustments. These smart features work together to keep your pool consistently clean and balanced with minimal effort. Plus, its energy-efficient design and durable, weather-resistant construction ensure it can handle year-round use, no matter the climate.
With the CORE55 offering considerable benefits, it’s important for potential users to recognize the initial investment and the costs associated with replacing the titanium cell down the line. A few customers have noted that customer service is responsive overall, but the warranty claims process may feel a bit lengthy, which could impact user experience.
Specifications:
- Brand: CircuPool
- Titanium cell technology
- Maximum Capacity: 55,000 gallons
- Digital control with LED indicators
- Self-cleaning function
- Energy-efficient operation
- Weather-proof construction
- Easy DIY installation
- Salt Salinity Range: 3000-4500 ppm
Pros:
- Handles large pool volumes
- Low maintenance design
- High durability and robustness
- Energy-efficient and eco-friendly
- User-friendly digital controls
Cons:
- Replacement parts can be expensive
- Complex warranty claim process
- May require professional installation
- Requires specific operating conditions
6. Bestway Salt Water Pool System
Bestway’s saltwater pool system is for above-ground pools, delivering an efficient solution to simplify maintenance while enhancing user comfort. Its versatility makes it suitable for pools of various sizes, supporting up to 7,000 gallons. The system’s straightforward setup process, along with its user-friendly control panel, ensures seamless operation and easy monitoring, making it a convenient choice for pool owners.
Pool maintenance becomes a breeze with Bestway’s innovative system, featuring a self-cleaning mode that minimizes hands-on work. It’s designed for those who want to spend more time enjoying their pool and less time maintaining it. The system also comes with convenient test strips and versatile adaptors to accommodate different pool sizes, underscoring its commitment to easy and efficient use.
While the system works well initially, some users have experienced wear and tear on components after extended use, diminishing its effectiveness. Additionally, the customer service team has sometimes been slow to address these problems, which could be a red flag for anyone seeking a more reliable, low-maintenance solution.
Specifications:
- Brand: Bestway
- Maximum Capacity: 7,000 gallons
- Includes 50 test strips
- Automatic self-cleaning mode
- Touch screen control panel
- Adaptors for different pools included
- Green/red LED indicators
- Produces 6 grams of chlorine per hour
- Minimum Flow Rate: 330 gallons
- Self-locking function for safety
Pros:
- Easy installation and setup
- Adaptable to various pool sizes
- Includes necessary accessories
- Automated cleaning reduces maintenance
- User-friendly digital controls
Cons:
- Longevity and durability concerns
- May struggle in larger pools
- Requires frequent monitoring and adjustments
7. ChlorWorks Salt Water Pool System
ChlorWorks delivers an advanced saltwater pool system specifically designed for medium-sized inground pools, providing a gentle swimming experience through efficient chlorine generation. This system softens pool water, reducing irritation to the skin and eyes. Equipped with an intelligent control panel, it displays essential metrics such as salt salinity, water temperature, and system performance, giving pool owners full control over their pool’s environment.
With its user-friendly knob design, adjusting chlorine levels is as simple as turning a dial. This straightforward control system caters to those who prefer uncomplicated solutions for pool maintenance. Automatic chlorine regulation keeps your water in perfect condition with little effort required. Built to endure the elements, the weather-resistant construction ensures it performs reliably year after year.
Although highly beneficial, this system does come with a few limitations. Some users have mentioned that the salt readings on the control panel can be inaccurate, leading to recalibration or customer service involvement. Additionally, while the system is generally reliable, the short one-year warranty and varying levels of customer service support may be a concern for those needing ongoing assistance.
Specifications:
- Brand: CHLORWORKS
- Suitable for up to 25,000 gallons
- Intelligent control panel
- Simple knob chlorine output adjustment
- Salt level calibration function
- Iron box construction, waterproof
- Minimal maintenance required
- Displays working volts and amps
- Measures water temperature
Pros:
- Enhances swimming comfort
- Durable and weather-proof
- Easy chlorine output adjustment
- Minimal maintenance needed
- Informative control panel
Cons:
- Calibration may be needed frequently
- Some reports of inaccurate salt readings
- May require professional installation
Factors To Consider When Choosing A Saltwater Pool System
Even though we have provided a detailed review of 7 salt water pool systems, selecting the right chlorinator for your pool that suits your requirements and preferences is a bit challenging. So, we came up with a guide that explains what factors to consider and how to choose the best option for a clean, and comfortable swimming experience.
1. Pool Size And Shape
The pool size and shape are essential to consider for a perfect purchase of your salt-water pool system. Firstly, the pool size determines the required salt dispenser and filtration equipment. For instance, a larger pool requires more salt and high filtration equipment compared to a pool of a smaller size. Secondly, the pool shape will aid in the ease of maintenance and cleaning. For instance, rectangular pools (square or round shapes) are easier to clean and maintain than curvy (or irregular shapes like kidney-shaped) pools.
2. Pool Water Capacity & Usage Patterns
Besides pool size and shape, you need to assess the pool water capacity before selecting the chlorine generator. For this, compare the gallon capacity of your pool and the maximum gallon rating of your pool system. As per the standard recommendations, choose a generator with a 1.5 to 2 times larger gallon rating than your pool size. The chlorine output capacities vary in different models, and you need to choose the one offering much chlorine output for your pool. Thus, it maintains proper chlorine levels in the pool and ensures optimal water sanitation, resulting in a longer lifespan of your generator.
|
Pool Size |
Pool Capacity |
|
Large Indoor Pools |
15,000 to 20,000 gallons |
|
Commercial Pools (small pools for hotels or spas to large water park pools) |
Up to 35,000 gallons |
|
Smaller Pools (small in-ground or above-ground pools for residential use) |
1500 to 5000 gallons |
Coming to the pool’s usage pattern, choose a saltwater pool system with a higher chlorine output for pools experiencing frequent gathering or heavy usage. Alternatively, if the pool has less frequent gatherings, then go with a generator with low chlorine output. So, based on the pool usage, you need to select the chlorine generator without any further issues.
3. Climate And Location
Do you know that the pool’s location can impact your chlorinator’s purchase? Yes, climatic conditions and location play a key role in its selection.
- Location – Usually, the water’s boiling point is low at high elevations, which affects the water chemistry in higher altitudes. Thus, it impacts the chlorinator’s effectiveness and overall water balance. While areas with high humidity cause algae growth and water evaporation, resulting in often testing and adjusting the water. For areas with constant wind exposure, the pool water experiences increased evaporation and higher salt levels. If your pool has nearby trees and plants, then the leaves and debris might contaminate the pool water, leaving you with quite often cleaning and filtration.
- Climatic Conditions – Climatic conditions like temperature, rainfall, or sun exposure will impact the pool chlorinator. Here’s how – A warmer climate or place with excessive sun exposure will increase algae growth and evaporate water, resulting in more frequent maintenance. Whereas, colder climate needs winterization measures to prevent freezing and damage. For places with heavy rainfall, the salt concentration gets diluted in the pool water and thereby causes contaminants.
- Preventive Measure – Whatever the climatic condition in your pool location, it leaves the pool with significantly high chlorine demand. You need to closely monitor the salt levels and use this chlorinator quite often to adjust the salt levels. For this, you need to purchase a chlorine generator offering high chlorine output.
4. Installation Requirements
Be it a new pool or converting the existing pool, you need to consider ease of installation before purchasing the saltwater pool system. Mostly, saltwater pool systems require professional hiring for their proper installation, safety, and function.
Choose user-friendly options having intuitive controls and easy operation with detailed instructions. In case of looking to set this generator in your existing pool, then check the compatibility with pool equipment (filters, pumps) for hassle-free installation. Also, look for easy-to-install systems or compact models with less wiring that fit into the existing pool without much alterations or plumbing. Make sure to keep all required tools or equipment handy for a smooth installation.
5. Maintenance
Even though the saltwater pool system has less maintenance compared to standard chlorine pool treatments, it still requires monitoring and upkeep. Follow these tips to ensure optimal performance.
- Avoid running your saltwater pool system or adding too much salt to the pool water. This results in ill effects on your pool’s surface and irritates the swimmers.
- Regularly monitor the salt concentration and adjust the salt level by adding or diluting it in the water.
- The pH balance of the water (7.2 and above) is prior and you need to use pool chemicals to adjust the pH as required.
- Use alkalinity increaser or decreaser products on a regular basis to maintain the alkalinity (80 – 120 ppm). This prevents any irritation caused due to extended swimming.
- The salt cell in this chlorinator produces chlorine, yet you have to manually check and add some chlorine occasionally to the pool.
- For proper filtration & cleaning, you need to clean the filter cartridge regularly and check whether the filters run daily for the set hours.
- However, an improperly used salt chlorinator might damage the pool. So, the main problem is that the saltwater chlorinator itself needs some professional maintenance and repairs rather than the pool.
- Shock the pool at regular intervals to kill the algae. Also, use some preventive measures like algaecides to maintain a clean pool.
- Always use a pool cover while not using the pool to prevent evaporation, retain heat, and keep the water clean.
6. Durability
Always prefer to choose a durable system that is made of high-quality corrosion-resistant materials and comes with a long warranty. This kind of choice will ensure long-term reliability and performance, making your purchase valuable.
7. Salt Cell Capacity
The output capacity of the salt cell will determine the quantity of chlorine it produces. A larger pool requires a salt cell with a higher output capacity compared to a smaller pool. However, some factors like water temperature, pH, and calcium hardness will affect the overall cell’s performance.
For instance, a pool with up to 10,000 gallons capacity requires a system with low salt cell life. A pool with up to 18000 gallons capacity requires a generator with moderate salt cell life. A pool with up to 30,000 gallons capacity needs a chlorinator with high salt cell life, and a pool with above 30,000 gallons capacity requires very high salt cell life. So, based on your pool capacity, you need to choose the generator with the required salt cell life for proper maintenance of the pool.
FAQs:
The frequency of cleaning your saltwater pump cell depends on various factors like pool usage, water hardness, and the type of your salt cell. Most experts suggest checking the cell monthly and cleaning it (if required). The signs that initiate cleaning will be scaling on the cell plates, lower chlorine levels, or reduced water flow. Ask a pool expert or follow your manufacturer’s guidelines to get a clear idea of when to clean the cell.
Yes, these saltwater systems work in most swimming pools, but you need to consider the compatibility of water chemistry, generator equipment, and pool structure. For example, a pool with metal parts like copper or iron requires extra filtration to prevent staining. Also, some coatings or finishes won’t suit these generators. So, consulting a pool professional is always advisable before making the purchase decision.
Take a salt test kit, available at pool supply stores to test the salt level in your pool. Collect a water sample and check the salt concentration by following the instructions provided. Then compare the result to the standard levels for your system. If the salt is too high, dilute it with fresh water, and if it is too low, then add more salt to it.
Saltwater pumps experience several issues that include scaling (building up mineral deposits and reducing chlorine production), corrosion (imbalanced water results in causing damage), debris (clogging the filter/impeller that lowers water flow & efficiency), and electrical problems (malfunctioning of motor or control board due to power surges). Sometimes, the salt cell might be less efficient or fail over time.
The impact of weather is much higher for saltwater pool systems. Cold weather creates salt crystals that harm pool equipment, whereas hot weather causes water evaporation, increased salt levels, and low water levels in the pool. Rainfall will eventually dilute the salt quantity, reducing chlorine production. Strong winds will bring algae and debris that make the overall filtration process a bit harder.
Conclusion
Choosing the right saltwater pool system can make your pool experience better with less maintenance and fewer chemicals. For top performance, the Hayward W3AQ-TROL-RJ is a reliable and easy-to-use option. The CircuPool CORE55 is efficient and durable, fitting different pool sizes well. If you’re on a budget, the Saltron Mini is a compact and affordable choice without losing quality. These systems can help you enjoy a clean, soft-water swim that suits your needs.
One Response
Fantastic post! Your detailed breakdown of saltwater pool systems is incredibly helpful. It’s clear that you’ve done thorough research to highlight the best options available. The emphasis on capacity, ease of use, and durability really guides readers in making an informed choice. Thanks for simplifying pool maintenance for us!